Google Analytics and data transfers to the US: from Schrems II to the Data Privacy Framework

In 2022, several European data protection authorities found that the use of Google Analytics on certain websites breached the GDPR, because visitors' data reached the United States without the safeguards required by EU law. Since July 2023, transfers to participating US companies can rely on an adequacy decision of the European Commission. This article sets out the stages, the questions that remain open and the privacy settings available in Google Analytics 4.

Man working on a laptop in an office in the evening.

The Schrems II judgment

In its judgment of 16 July 2020 in Case C-311/18 (Schrems II), the Court of Justice of the European Union invalidated Commission Decision 2016/1250 on the EU-US Privacy Shield, on which transfers to participating US companies had relied until then.

The Court upheld the validity of the standard contractual clauses, provided they include effective mechanisms that make it possible, in practice, to ensure the level of protection required by EU law. Where the clauses cannot be complied with in the third country and protection cannot be ensured by other means, supervisory authorities are required to suspend or prohibit the transfer.

The Google Analytics complaints

On 17 August 2020, the organisation noyb announced 101 complaints against EU controllers that used Google Analytics or Facebook Connect on their websites. The first decisions followed in 2022:

  • Austria: the data protection authority (DSB) found that the use of Google Analytics on the website concerned breached the GDPR. The decision, the first on the 101 complaints, was made public on 13 January 2022.
  • Italy: on 23 June 2022, the Italian authority (Garante) stated that a website using Google Analytics without the safeguards provided by the GDPR breaches data protection law, because it transfers users' data to the United States, a country without an adequate level of protection. The operator was given 90 days to comply.

The decisions concerned specific cases and were adopted before the transfer framework described below.

  1. The CJEU invalidates the Privacy Shield (Schrems II).
  2. noyb files 101 complaints about Google Analytics and Facebook Connect.
  3. The Austrian authority's decision is published.
  4. The Italian authority announces its Google Analytics decision.
  5. The Commission adopts the adequacy decision for the Data Privacy Framework.
  6. The Commission publishes its first periodic review of the framework.
  7. The EU General Court dismisses the action for annulment (T-553/23).
  8. An appeal is brought before the Court of Justice (C-703/25 P).
  9. The EDPB asks the Commission to assess the effects of Trump v. Slaughter.

The EU-US Data Privacy Framework

On 10 July 2023, the European Commission adopted Implementing Decision (EU) 2023/1795 on the EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework (DPF). According to the Commission, personal data can flow safely from the EU to US companies participating in the framework, without additional data protection safeguards. US companies join by committing to comply with a detailed set of privacy obligations.

The Romanian authority, ANSPDCP, describes the framework on its website as a legal mechanism that can be used to transfer data from the EU to participating US organisations without additional safeguards. In its policy on data transfer frameworks, Google states that Google LLC and its wholly-owned US subsidiaries, unless explicitly excluded, have certified that they adhere to the DPF Principles.

The decision covers only transfers to participating organisations. For other recipients, the transfer tools in Chapter V of the GDPR, such as standard contractual clauses, continue to apply.

Office building with lit windows at night.

What remains open

  • Periodic review: in its first review report, of 9 October 2024, the Commission concluded that the US authorities had put in place the structures and procedures necessary for the framework to function effectively. The Commission considered it appropriate to carry out the next review after three years.
  • Court challenge: on 3 September 2025, the EU General Court dismissed in its entirety the action for annulment brought by Philippe Latombe in Case T-553/23, finding that the United States ensured an adequate level of protection on the date the decision was adopted. On 31 October 2025, the applicant appealed to the Court of Justice (Case C-703/25 P).
  • Independence of US authorities: on 29 June 2026, the US Supreme Court held in Trump v. Slaughter that the Commissioners of the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) are subject to the control of the US President, including the power to remove them. On 31 July 2026, the EDPB Chair wrote to European Commissioner Michael McGrath that the existence and effective functioning of one or more independent supervisory authorities in the third country is one of the key elements of an adequacy assessment. The letter points out that the DPF decision explicitly refers to the FTC's independence and asks the Commission to closely assess whether the judgment affects the functioning of the decision.

The adequacy decision remains applicable for as long as it is not amended, suspended or repealed by the Commission or invalidated by the Court of Justice.

Privacy settings in Google Analytics 4

Independently of the transfer framework, Google Analytics 4 offers settings that limit the data collected. According to Google's documentation:

  • IP addresses: Google Analytics does not log or store individual IP addresses of users in the EU, Switzerland and the UK. For this traffic, the IP address is used only to derive approximate location and is then discarded immediately.
  • Data retention: in standard properties, event-level data can be kept for 2 or 14 months. The setting affects explorations and funnel reports, not standard aggregated reports.
  • Granular location and device data: collection can be switched off by region. Google Analytics then no longer collects, among other things, the city, the device brand and model, and the browser's User-Agent string. Google notes that switching it off significantly reduces the volume of modelled key events for that region.
  • Google signals: collection can be switched on or off by region. Without it, remarketing lists based on third-party advertising identifiers, advertising reports and demographics and interests are not available.

These settings concern the data processed by Google, not the cookie rules. Google Analytics uses cookies, and storing them on the visitor's device falls under Article 5(3) of the ePrivacy Directive, transposed in Romania by Article 4(5) of Law No 506/2004. How the visitor's choice reaches Google tags is explained in the article on Consent Mode v2 on Shopify, and the effect of refusal on measurement in the article on cookie refusal.

Checklist for the store

Based on the documents above, the set-up can be reviewed with the following questions. The list is a working tool, not a guarantee of compliance, and does not replace legal advice.

  • Data retention: what period is set in the GA4 property, and is it necessary for the purpose pursued?
  • Regions: are granular location and device data and Google signals switched off for the EU if they are not used?
  • Information: does the store's privacy policy name Google as a recipient and mention the transfer of data to the US and its legal basis, as Article 13 of the GDPR requires?
  • Consent: do the Google Analytics tags take the visitor's choice into account, and is refusal respected?

About Consentia

Consentia is a cookie consent app for Shopify stores. Further information is available on the Features page. A website can also be checked with our free cookie scanner.

Related articles

Sources: CJEU, press release No 91/20 (Schrems II) · noyb, the 101 complaints · noyb, the Austrian authority's decision · Garante, press release of 23 June 2022 · European Commission, press release of 10 July 2023 · ANSPDCP, EU-US Data Privacy Framework (in Romanian) · Google, data transfer frameworks · European Commission, first periodic review, COM(2024) 451 · EU General Court, press release No 106/25 (Latombe) · Official Journal, Case C-703/25 P · EDPB, letter of 31 July 2026 · Google Analytics Help: EU-focused data and privacy, data retention, privacy controls. Photos: Unsplash.

Consentia for Shopify.

Consentia is available on the Shopify App Store. For more information, please contact us.