The cookie policy: what information it must contain

Consent to cookies is valid only if the visitor was informed before giving it. Law No 506/2004, the GDPR, the case law of the Court of Justice and the guidelines of European authorities set out what the visitor must be told and how the information must be presented. This article brings them together into a working structure for an online store's cookie policy.

Man with glasses working on a laptop in an office.

What Law No 506/2004 requires

Under Article 4(5) of Law No 506/2004, which transposes the ePrivacy Directive in Romania, storing information on the visitor's device or accessing information already stored there is allowed only if the visitor has consented after receiving clear and complete information. The information must:

  • be presented in language that is easy to understand and be easily accessible;
  • state the purpose of processing the information stored or accessed.

Where the site allows third parties to store or access information on the visitor's device, the information must also cover the general purpose of their processing and how the visitor can use the browser settings or similar technologies to delete the information or refuse third-party access.

Paragraph (6) provides two exceptions to the consent requirement: operations carried out solely to transmit a communication over an electronic communications network, and operations strictly necessary to provide an information society service explicitly requested by the visitor.

What the GDPR and the Court of Justice add

Where cookies are used to process personal data, the GDPR also applies. Article 12(1) requires information to be provided in a concise, transparent, intelligible and easily accessible form, using clear and plain language. Article 13 lists the information to be given when data is collected, including:

  • the identity and contact details of the controller;
  • the purposes and legal basis of the processing;
  • the recipients or categories of recipients;
  • any intention to transfer data to a third country;
  • the storage period or the criteria used to determine it;
  • the right to withdraw consent at any time and the right to lodge a complaint with a supervisory authority.

In Planet49 (C-673/17, judgment of 1 October 2019), the Court of Justice held that the information given to the user includes the duration of the operation of cookies and whether or not third parties may have access to them.

The minimum for informed consent

The EDPB's Guidelines 05/2020 on consent list, in paragraph 64, the minimum information required for consent to be valid:

  1. WhoThe controller's identity.
  2. WhyThe purpose of each processing operation for which consent is sought.
  3. What dataThe type of data collected and used.
  4. WithdrawalThe existence of the right to withdraw consent.
  5. Automated decisionsThe use of data for automated individual decisions, where relevant.
  6. TransfersThe risks of transfers without an adequacy decision and appropriate safeguards.
Based on the EDPB's Guidelines 05/2020, version 1.1, paragraph 64.

Under paragraph 65, where several controllers, including joint controllers, rely on the same consent, all of them should be named. Processors do not need to be named for consent to be valid, but Articles 13 and 14 of the GDPR require a full list of recipients or categories of recipients, processors included.

The Guidelines accept that some of the information required by Articles 13 and 14 may appear elsewhere than in the consent request, for example in the privacy notice (paragraph 72). They also state that controllers cannot use long privacy policies that are difficult to understand or statements full of legal jargon (paragraph 67).

Layered information

The Article 29 Working Party's Guidelines on transparency (WP260 rev.01) recommend layered privacy statements that link to the various categories of information, rather than a single notice displayed in full, in order to avoid information fatigue (paragraph 35). The first layer should include the purposes of processing, the identity of the controller and a description of the data subject's rights, as well as the processing with the greatest impact or that could surprise the data subject (paragraph 36). The full information must also be available in one single place or one complete document (paragraph 17).

The French authority (CNIL) applies the same approach to cookies. Under its 2020 recommendation, the exhaustive and regularly updated list of controllers must be made available to users when their consent is collected and may sit at a second level, reached through a link or a button. The CNIL's guidelines state that a mere reference to the general terms of use is not sufficient.

Applied to an online store, the structure could look like this:

  • The banner (first layer): the store's identity, the purposes by category, the option to accept, to refuse and to choose by category, and a link to the cookie policy.
  • The cookie policy (second layer): the full list of cookies and third parties, with purpose, duration and third-party access, and how to withdraw consent.
  • The privacy policy: the information required by Articles 13 and 14 of the GDPR for all of the store's processing.
Two people reviewing documents at a table.

The cookie list

For each cookie, the information above can be presented in a table with the name, provider, purpose and duration. The example below uses three cookies from the list published by Shopify, where they appear under “Cookies Necessary for the Functioning of the Store”.

CookieProviderPurpose, according to ShopifyDuration
cartShopifyContains information related to the user's cart.91 days
_shopify_essentialShopifyContains essential information for the correct functionality of a store, such as session and checkout information.1 year
localizationShopifyUsed to localise the cart to the correct country.1 year

For analytics and advertising cookies, the table also names the third party that sets them: Planet49 requires information on third-party access, and paragraph 65 of Guidelines 05/2020 requires the controllers relying on consent to be named.

Wording to avoid

WP260 gives examples of poor practice (paragraph 12), such as “We may use your personal data to develop new services” or “We may use your personal data for research purposes”, because they do not make clear what processing takes place. Under paragraph 13, qualifiers such as “may”, “might”, “some”, “often” and “possible” should be avoided. Information should be concrete and definitive.

On Shopify

Shopify publishes the list of cookies it uses, with their names, purposes and durations, grouped into categories: cookies necessary for the functioning of the store, reporting and analytics, marketing and advertising, and social media and content. The list can serve as a starting point for the store's inventory, together with the cookies set by installed apps and tags.

The Shopify Help Center states that merchants are responsible for the accuracy of their published policies and for following them, and that automation does not replace their responsibility to identify missing information.

Checklist for the store's policy

Based on the documents above, a cookie policy can be reviewed with the following questions. The list is a working tool, not a guarantee of compliance, and does not replace legal advice.

  • Inventory: does the list include every cookie, including those of apps and tags added to the theme code?
  • Details: are the provider, purpose, duration and third-party access given for each cookie?
  • Third parties: are all controllers relying on the visitor's consent named?
  • Access: can the policy be opened from the banner and from every page of the store?
  • Language: does the text avoid vague wording such as “we may use”?
  • Updates: is the list reviewed whenever a new app or tag is installed?

About Consentia

Consentia is a cookie consent app for Shopify stores. Further information is available on the Features page. A website can also be checked with our free cookie scanner.

Related articles

Sources: ANSPDCP, Law No 506/2004 (in Romanian) · Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR) · CJEU, press release No 125/19 (Planet49) · EDPB, Guidelines 05/2020, version 1.1 · Article 29 Working Party, WP260 rev.01 · CNIL: 2020 recommendation, 2020 guidelines (in French) · Shopify, cookie policy · Shopify Help Center, store policies. Photos: Unsplash.

Consentia for Shopify.

Consentia is available on the Shopify App Store. For more information, please contact us.