The general rule
Article 12(1) of Law No 506/2004 prohibits commercial communications by email unless the subscriber or user concerned has given prior express consent to receive them. The same rule applies to automated calling systems that do not require human intervention, to fax and to any other method using publicly available electronic communications services. Under paragraph (4), it also applies, with the necessary adjustments, to subscribers that are legal persons.
The conditions for consent are those of the GDPR. Article 4(11) defines consent as a freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous indication of the data subject's wishes, by a statement or by a clear affirmative action. Recital 32 states that silence, pre-ticked boxes or inactivity should not constitute consent. Under Article 7(1), the controller must be able to demonstrate that the person has consented.
The exception for existing customers
Paragraph (2) of the same article allows a customer's email address to be used without the consent required by paragraph (1) if three conditions are met:
- Origin of the address: the address was obtained directly from the customer in the context of the sale of a product or service.
- Content of the messages: the communications concern similar products or services sold by the same person.
- Opportunity to object: the customer is clearly and expressly given the opportunity to object to such use, free of charge and by simple means, both when the address is collected and with each message, if they did not object initially.
The exception mirrors Article 13(2) of Directive 2002/58/EC and is tied to a sale: the text refers to an address obtained in the context of a sale. For an address entered in a sign-up form without a purchase, the rule in paragraph (1) applies.
- Sign-up without a purchaseExpress consent is required before the first message.
- Customer who has purchasedMessages about similar products are allowed, with an opportunity to object at collection and in every message.
- The person has objectedThe data is no longer processed for direct marketing.
Objection, withdrawal and response time
Article 21(2) of the GDPR gives data subjects the right to object at any time to the processing of their data for direct marketing, including profiling related to it. Under Article 21(3), once they object, the data is no longer processed for that purpose.
Where messages are sent on the basis of consent, Article 7(3) of the GDPR requires withdrawal to be as easy as giving consent. The EDPB's Guidelines 05/2020 state that if consent was given with a single click, it must be possible to withdraw it just as easily.
Article 12(3) of the GDPR requires the controller to respond to requests from data subjects without undue delay and within one month of receipt at the latest. That period may be extended by two further months, taking into account the complexity and number of requests. Two of the cases sanctioned by ANSPDCP and described below arose from unsubscribe requests that went unanswered.
The sender's identity
Article 12(3) of Law No 506/2004 prohibits, in all cases, marketing emails that conceal the real identity of the person on whose behalf they are sent, as well as emails that do not give a valid address to which the recipient can send a request to stop such communications.
Tracking pixels in emails
The EDPB's Guidelines 2/2023 (version 2.0) describe a tracking pixel as a hyperlink to a resource, usually an image file, embedded in a website or an email. The Guidelines give the example of a sender who includes a pixel in an email to detect when the recipient reads it.
According to the Guidelines, distributing the pixel to the recipient's device constitutes storage, at the very least through the caching mechanism of the client-side software, even if that storage is not permanent. Collecting identifiers added to images or URLs constitutes, in turn, gaining access. Article 5(3) of the ePrivacy Directive, transposed in Romania by Article 4(5) of Law No 506/2004, therefore applies to both operations.
The Guidelines do not address the exemptions from Article 5(3): whether consent is required has to be assessed separately for each situation. How pixels work and how responsibility is shared is covered in the article on advertising pixels.
What ANSPDCP has sanctioned
The Authority's press releases describe, among others, the situations below. The controllers are not named here; details are available in the press releases listed under the sources.
- 6 August 2026: commercial communications through automated calling systems, without the recipients' prior express consent. A fine of RON 50,000 for breaching Article 12(1) of Law No 506/2004, alongside GDPR fines for other breaches found in the same investigation.
- 8 January 2026: marketing emails sent to a person who had objected, without a simple and free means of objecting to direct marketing. A fine of RON 5,000 for breaching Article 12(1) and (2) of Law No 506/2004 and a fine of RON 10,178 (the equivalent of EUR 2,000) for breaching Articles 12 to 14 of the GDPR, on information.
- 26 November 2025: marketing emails sent without proof of the recipient's consent; the controller had collected addresses and sent messages without first checking that the addresses came from their owners. Fines of RON 5,084 (the equivalent of EUR 1,000) for breaching Article 6(1)(a) of the GDPR and RON 10,169 (the equivalent of EUR 2,000) for breaching Article 25.
- 24 April 2023: marketing text messages that continued after the person had asked, by email, to unsubscribe, a request the controller had not answered within the legal time limit. A fine of RON 4,947.9 (the equivalent of EUR 1,000) for breaching Articles 12(3) and 21 of the GDPR.
A breach of Article 12 of Law No 506/2004 is a contravention under Article 13(1)(q). The fine ranges from RON 5,000 to RON 100,000, and for companies with a turnover above RON 5,000,000 it can reach 2% of turnover. Cookie-related sanctions under the same law are covered in the article on ANSPDCP fines.
On Shopify
The email marketing sign-up option is configured under Settings > Checkout, in the “Marketing opt-in” section. According to the Shopify Help Center:
- The sign-up checkbox: it can be shown at checkout or at sign-in. The merchant decides whether it is preselected and in which regions, either automatically, based on local legislation (“Regions recommended by Shopify”), or manually (“Regions you choose”). Customers can deselect it.
- When consent is recorded: Shopify captures consent at checkout, when the customer selects the checkbox and proceeds to the next step.
- Double opt-in: after signing up, the customer automatically receives an email with a link to confirm that they want to receive marketing. Customers who subscribed before the option was activated are not asked to confirm. Shopify notes that in some countries double opt-in is required by law.
Checklist for the store's emails
Based on the texts above, a store's practice can be reviewed with the following questions. The list is a working tool, not a guarantee of compliance, and does not replace legal advice.
- Origin: do you know, for every address on the list, whether it comes from a sign-up with consent or from a sale?
- Proof: can you show when and how each person subscribed?
- The sign-up checkbox: for regions in the Union, is the checkbox unticked by default, in line with Recital 32 of the GDPR?
- Unsubscribing: does every message offer a simple and free way to unsubscribe, and are requests answered on time?
- The sender: do messages show the store's real identity and a valid address for stopping communications?
- Pixels: have you assessed whether the pixels that measure email opens require consent?
About Consentia
Consentia is a cookie consent app for Shopify stores. Further information is available on the Features page. A website can also be checked with our free cookie scanner.
Related articles
- Advertising pixels and consent: the store owner's responsibility
- Cookie fines in Romania: what Law No 506/2004 requires and what ANSPDCP has sanctioned
- The cookie policy: what information it must contain
Sources: ANSPDCP, Law No 506/2004 · Directive 2002/58/EC · Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR) · EDPB, Guidelines 2/2023, version 2.0 · EDPB, Guidelines 05/2020, version 1.1 · ANSPDCP press releases of 6 August 2026, 8 January 2026, 26 November 2025 and 24 April 2023 (in Romanian) · Shopify Help Center, collecting customer contact information. Photos: Unsplash.